New Default/Sitewide Fonts Not Loading

I’m trying to replace display and body fonts sitewide using the Theme Panel. They’re not loading.

I’ve removed all custom font calls from every page, template and element. When I view the Manager panel, it says Default font for every page, template, block and element.

In the Theme panel, I have Google Fonts turned on. I’m loading all the correct font weights. I’ve specified the fonts in the General and Pages tabs, for body and Hs. I’ve turned *off* loading for the default Google fonts.

This is not a page caching issue.

The new body font appears in one place: body copy for new posts and pages.

Is there something I’m missing or forgetting to do?

Thank you.